Justin Rose wins $10 million FedExCup Point System Fiasco

Justin Rose won the FedExCup bonus of $10 million on points but never won a playoff tournament which again raises questions about the format which will be revised again in 2019 to a handicap event which could be more confusing to golf fans.

Justin Rose won the FedExCup bonus of $10 million on points though his three over par effort on Sunday September 23 at the Tour Championship put him in a fourth-place tie for the tournament behind winner Tiger Woods.

Don’t ask me to explain the points system since not even the players say they are clear about it. And if you agree with me then figuring out next year’s point system will turn into an even bigger fiasco.

We are told by the PGA Tour media machine that we will no longer see Steve Sands and his white board, but that is not a promise. Fans will get a bonus, if you want to call it one, with the Golf Channel telling us every two minutes the player “controls his own destiny.” Inane clichés are the foundation to televised golf.

The current point system is so dysfunctional it’s become a long-running joke among golfers everywhere. Justin Rose did not win a playoff tournament and he entered the final event as the No. 1 ranked player in the world. Rose finished fourth and won the FedExCup but lost his No. 1 ranking to Dustin Johnson. Go figure?

In 2019 the player with the lowest gross score for the Tour Championship still may not win the FedExCup because the tournament will be a handicap event. The points leader at the end of the playoffs starts the Tour Championship with a score of -10 strokes, second in points with -8 and so on down to those at 26 through 30 who get no handicap adjustment to their score.

If in place this year points leader Bryson DeChambeau with a 19th place score of -1 would have finished at -11. Woods would have deducted two strokes for a -13, second place Billy Horschel four strokes putting him also at -13 and Dustin Johnson who finished in third four shots behind Woods would have used his six-stroke handicap for a three-way tie at -13.

Sounds like a playoff or maybe matching cards like at the member-guest, but a heck of a lot more confusing?

Justin Rose won the FedExCup and Tiger Woods won the Tour Championship and his 80th career victory which could turn into the greatest comeback story in sports history as well as the No. 1 golf story of the year.

In fact, Rose would win both the tournament and the FedExCup because his fourth-place -6 would be handicap-adjusted by eight shots giving him -14.

Coincidence? I don’t know but trying to keep this all straight made my brain hurt so I didn’t go back to see what would have happened in 2017 when Xander Schauffele won the Tour Championship and Justin Thomas the FedExCup.

When I first read the press release describing the new system my reaction was, “A handicap event…really?”

Okay, stroke-play I’ll give you two a side, and if I beat you by less than four shots you win. Sounds to me like the conversation on the first tee of every golf course in the country on a Saturday morning. Well that’s what the FedEx Cup is changing to. We can only look at the bright side and hope this handicap system won’t be as big a pain in the cerebral cortex as the point system.

The PGA Tour wants to finish the year with only one winner not two like Woods and Rose or Schauffele and Thomas.

The new plan also had to satisfy the sponsors FedEx and Southern Company by having the best chance to put the top players on display plus make the media happy and of course the fans. The players will show up regardless, but the new plan does bump the FedExCup payout from $25 million to $60 million with $15 million for the winner up from $10 million.

Players will still earn regular season points for determining who gets to the playoffs but its still foggy if the FedExCup and the Tour Championship will be easier to understand. It means however Steve Sands will have to find another job on Tour Championship Sunday.

It also means the distribution of wealth to PGA Tour marquee players will hit unprecedented levels!

And, based on the TV ratings for the final round of this year’s Tour Championship with Tiger Woods winning the tournament but not the FedExCup, it makes me wonder: Are golf fans interested in the FedExCup points system or in Tiger Woods winning again? I think we all know the answer!

Ed is a national award-winning golf journalist and has carried on a lifelong love affair with the game. His work covering the business of golf, equipment, golf personalities and travel is prominently featured in numerous print and electronic publications. He has competed in tournament golf both as an amateur and senior professional and though his competitive days are behind him, Ed still plays regularly and carries a handicap of 4. He lives on a water hazard in suburban Orlando. His email address is GolfScribe@outlook.com.

Leave a Reply

Notify of