James Starnes: This Senior Amateur is Good

    James Starnes has carved out an impressive amateur career in his senior years after grinding out a 9-5 job for 40 years.

    FORT MYERS, Florida – At age 66, Jim Starnes is playing the best golf of his life. He’s become one of the more accomplished senior golfers in Florida and there’s no secret behind his success.

    “It’s a combination of being highly competitive and pretty good hand-eye coordination and loving the game and loving to practice,” he said.
    Starnes retired in May of 2021 and he estimates he usually plays golf five days a week, sometimes more. He’s played about 120 competitive rounds this year, and in 21 senior and super senior events he has finished in the top 10 a dozen times and won twice.

    In September, he parred his final eight holes to win the Senior Porter Cup Super Senior Division in Lewiston, N.Y., by a shot over three golfers. Last January, he overcame a first-round 77 to card consecutive 70s and win the Gateway Super Senior in his hometown of Fort Myers, Florida. He played the last 10 holes in 3 under to overcome a four-shot deficit and win by a shot.

    jamesstarnes 660
    James Starnes captured the prestigious 2016 Senior Dixie Amateur, his second AmateurGolf.com Senior Ranking victory that season.

    Last year, he also played in 21 senior or super senior events and finished in the top 10 13 times. He likes to say that he believes in “success through volume.” His significant other, Debi Cassis, attends nearly all of his tournaments.

    The 6-foot-1, 217-pound Starnes also works hard on his game, especially his putting. In front of an eight-foot mirror, he rolls 200 three-foot putts five days a week on the artificial green on the patio at his home overlooking a pond on the 13th hole at his home course of Fiddlesticks CC.

    “That’s allowed me to groove a stroke,” he said. “So whether it’s three feet or 30 feet, at least I’ve got pretty good rhythm and tempo and that’s allowed me to have the success I’ve had in the senior realm for the last nine or 10 years.”

    He also spends 60-90 minutes practicing his putting and the other parts of his game before each round.

    Tom Buckley, 47, is a frequent playing partner with Starnes at Fiddlesticks and calls him the best putter he’s played with.

    jamesstarnes 6501
    Since 2016 James Starnes has competed in about 18 national senior events every year dotted with several victories and a slew of top 10 finishes against an elite field of senior players most who maintain handicaps of +1 to plus +5.

    “He’s very still,” Buckley said. “He’s got quiet eyes and he has something that many amateur golfers don’t have – he’s never had the fear of having to putt the 3-footer coming back.”

    Starnes owns more than 20 Bobby Grace putters and played with them for more than 25 years, but about a month ago he was in a bit of a slump so he switched to a Rickie Fowler Odyssey Jailbird putter.

    “Sometimes you have to punish your putters by putting them in the closet,” he said.

    Soon after the switch, he carded a 66 at Fiddlesticks to shoot his age or better for the second time this year. A few days ago, he sank 120 feet of putts during a round.

    Starnes knew technology from his career of selling software and data so he worked with a company in India to create an app called “Gimme that putt” that’s available for $4.99 at the iPhone app store. You hover the cell phone over the cup and drag it to your ball to determine if it’s within the gimme distance that was agreed upon prior to each round. It can also measure distances for closest-to-the-pin contests. He’s considering donating the profits to the game of golf somehow.

    Starnes’ lowest handicap was a plus-3 and it’s still a plus 0.6 now. His lowest tournament round was a 67 and his lowest 54-hole total was 4 under while winning the 2016 SOS Founders Cup in Orlando.

    jamesstarnes 600
    When it comes to four-ball competition Starnes has an impressive record, shown here (far right) after wining the Super-Senior Four-Ball Championship at Fox Hollow Golf Club in Trinity, Florida October 3-4, 2022 with partner Steve Humphrey (2nd from rigth)

    At Fiddlesticks CC, he has captured three club championships and three senior club championships.

    He’s recorded six holes in one from 1981-2022.

    Starnes strives to get even better. He pointed out that he led six events this year entering the final round and won just two of them. He has set a goal of winning four or five events next year.

    Starnes played football, basketball and baseball while growing up in Gaithersburg, Maryland. The last year he played football, he started at quarterback as a ninth grader in a local weight-restricted league and his team finished 0-10-1 and didn’t score a point. That’s when he turned to golf.

    In 1974, he qualified for the U.S. Junior Amateur at Brooklawn CC in Fairfield, Conn., and his grandfather, Frank R. Lovell, a longtime USGA official, was on hand to watch him play. Starnes lost in the third round to eventual champion David Nevatt.

    Starnes comes from a golfing family. His grandmother headed the USGA Women’s Committee from 1974-77 and his mother, Mary Margaret Lovell, played in the U.S. Girls’ Junior three times.

    jamesstarnes side 650
    James Starnes credits his short game as his most valuable resource when competing against senior amateurs who maintain handicaps of scratch or better.

    Starnes played one year of golf at Florida Southern College in Lakeland, but he drifted away from the game as he grew older.

    “I’ve had periods of time where I abandoned the game,” he said, “either because of where I was living, where I was working or total frustration.”

    Starnes played only two or three rounds a year before he moved to Fiddlesticks in 2014 and began hitting 400-500 balls a day at the range in addition to rolling 200 putts a day. Within a year and a half, he lowered his handicap to scratch.

    In 2016, 42 years after his first, he qualified for his second USGA event, the U.S. Senior Amateur in St. Louis, and he reached the final 64. That year, Starnes also posted his two other senior victories at the Dixie Senior & Mid-Master and the SOS Founders Cup.

    In 2020, he reached the final 16 of the Golfweek Senior National Match Play and in 2016 and 2021 he played in the U.S. Senior Amateur.

    Starnes finished 10th in the 2018 Irish Senior Amateur and he has also competed in the British Senior Amateur, English Senior Amateur and Canadian Senior Amateur.

    JamesStarnes small
    Starnes hopes to play into his 80s.

    As impressed as Buckley is with Starnes’ putting, he’s equally dazzled by his neatly coiffed hair.

    “He doesn’t wear a hat on the golf course and that hair is perfect,” Buckley said.

    “I was born with a full head of hair and ever since then I’ve been a lucky man,” Starnes said.

    Starnes is inspired by the golfers he plays against who are in their 70s and even 80s.

    “I hope to still be kicking around tournament golf for another 10 or 15 years,” he said.

    On the web: AmateurGolf.com/…/James-Starnes

    Bill Doyle brings 45 years of professional sports writing experience to New England dot Golf. His resume includes 40 years as a sports writer for the Worcester Telegram & Gazette where he wrote a Sunday golf column and covered professional and amateur golf. He also wrote about all four of the major professional sports teams in the Boston area, mostly about the Boston Celtics, as well as college and local sports. Working for the newspaper in the city where Worcester Country Club hosted the inaugural Ryder Cup in 1927, Doyle covered the improbable comeback of the U.S. team at the 1999 Ryder Cup at The Country Club in Brookline. He also covered the 1988 U.S. Open at TCC, the 2001 and 2017 U.S. Senior Open championships at Salem Country Club, the U.S. Women’s Open championships at The Orchards in South Hadley in 2004 and at Newport Country Club in 2006, the PGA Tour stops at Pleasant Valley Country Club in Sutton for nearly 20 years and at TPC River Highlands in Cromwell, Connecticut, for several years; and every PGA Tour event at TPC Boston in Norton from the inaugural event in 2003. He will provide regular contributions ranging from interviews, travel, lifestyle, real estate, commentary and special assignments. Bill can be reached at bcdoyle15@charter.net.

    Leave a Reply

    Notify of